People still have to live while a dispute is being settled. They cannot suspend their need for work, care or somewhere safe to sleep until everyone has finished arguing. Any account of justice that treats this waiting time as empty has already missed something important.
The Human Rights Campaign reports that its foundation has filed for a preliminary injunction. Such an application asks a court to intervene before a case reaches its final resolution. The available headline does not establish the substance of this dispute or whether the application has succeeded, so it offers no sound basis for declaring either side right.
It does, however, invite a question that reaches beyond this case: who should bear the risk while we work out what is right?
Allowing an existing arrangement to continue can look like the cautious choice. Sometimes it is. Yet familiarity gives an arrangement no special moral innocence. If it is causing harm, leaving it untouched means that somebody continues to absorb the consequences of everyone else’s uncertainty.
An intervention carries risks too. A court can interrupt something lawful, create fresh difficulties or act on an incomplete understanding. Urgency does not make a claim true. Nor does the language of human rights remove the obligation to examine evidence.
The harder task is to compare the consequences of being wrong in either direction. What could be repaired later? What might be lost for good? Whose inconvenience is being weighed against whose ability to continue an ordinary life?
An evolving philosophy needs to take this problem seriously. Revising a belief after discovering an error is valuable, but it may offer very little to someone who lived under that error for years. Openness to correction needs practical expression: ways to challenge decisions, timely scrutiny and a willingness to limit damage before certainty arrives.
We cannot promise to decide everything correctly. We can refuse to treat the people waiting for our decisions as though their time costs nothing.