Article

The State Must Leave Room for Its Own Error

9 November 2026

A person facing execution has a future that other people have decided to close. Whatever the charge, whatever the verdict, that decision carries a disturbing assumption: that those exercising power can be trusted to make a judgement which nobody will ever be able to repair.

Iran News Update reports that Iranian authorities have executed four political prisoners and seven other inmates, describing an escalating wave of executions. The supplied reporting does not establish the circumstances of each case, and it would be wrong to invent them. But the distinction in that account deserves attention. Calling some prisoners political directs us towards questions of repression. Calling the others simply inmates can allow them to disappear into a category, as though their deaths require less examination.

A humane objection to irreversible punishment cannot depend entirely on whether we find the person sympathetic.

There is a serious difficulty here. People want protection from violence. Those who have suffered grave harm may reasonably resent an argument that appears more interested in the person convicted than in the person harmed. Any philosophy concerned with how we live together has to face that resentment without dismissing it as ignorance or cruelty. Safety matters. So does the demand that wrongdoing have consequences.

Yet neither demand establishes that a state must possess the power to kill a captive. Restraining someone and ending their life are different decisions. The second removes every possibility of correcting the first.

This is where the question reaches beyond punishment. How should human beings organise power when our knowledge is incomplete and our institutions are made of people who can be mistaken, frightened, ambitious or obedient? An open philosophy has to apply its willingness to question inherited beliefs to the machinery of judgement too. Otherwise openness remains something we enjoy in conversation while denying its practical consequences.

The work is uncomfortable because it requires concern to survive beyond affinity. We can distinguish between cases, assess evidence and acknowledge terrible wrongdoing without treating any person as beyond the need for safeguards.

Reports such as this should prompt demands for scrutiny of every case, including those whose political significance is less apparent. A correction issued after an execution may change the record. It cannot reach the person whose life depended on getting that record right.