Article

The Right to Challenge Must Survive the Machine

20 October 2026

When an official judgement enters someone’s life, the ability to question it matters rather more than how efficiently it was reached. A person may need to explain a circumstance that has been misunderstood, dispute a record, or insist that something apparently insignificant changes the whole case. There has to be somewhere for that explanation to go.

This is where the discussion of artificial intelligence and human rights becomes uncomfortable. A system can produce an answer without creating anyone willing, or able, to answer for it.

HESPRESS English reports that Fez hosted a training session for prosecution judicial officials on AI and human rights. The supplied report title establishes the subject of the session, but does not tell us what participants were taught or what followed. It nevertheless brings a practical philosophical problem into view: what must remain possible for a person when public authority begins relying on machine-generated assessments?

One answer worth pursuing is that every consequential assessment must remain genuinely open to challenge. That requires more than a complaints address. Someone with authority must be able to examine the reasoning, hear what the system has missed and change the outcome. Otherwise, the right to object becomes an administrative courtesy.

There is a reasonable objection here. Human judgement is hardly free from prejudice, fatigue or stubbornness. Refusing technical assistance simply because it is technical would leave those failings untouched. AI might help expose inconsistencies that people overlook. Whether a particular tool does so is something to establish through evidence, rather than enthusiasm or suspicion.

But the comparison with fallible human beings cannot settle the matter. A tool’s usefulness does not decide how much authority it should have. Even an assessment that is usually accurate can be wrong about the person standing before us.

That distinction ought to shape training, procurement and everyday practice. Officials need the competence and permission to disagree with a system, including when accepting its output would be quicker and easier to defend.

The difficult test comes when someone says, “You have misunderstood me.” If the official response amounts to “The system says otherwise”, we have built a process in which an answer can circulate indefinitely while responsibility has nowhere to settle.