For someone worried about whether their family will be safe, a debate about democratic safeguards can sound painfully remote. There is an immediate life to get through. Anyone asking people to defend those safeguards has to take that worry seriously, rather than treating it as evidence that frightened people have failed to understand democracy.
But fear cannot settle the question of how much power a government should have. It makes that question more urgent.
BBC correspondent Lucy Williamson’s report presents security and democracy as central issues in Israel’s approaching general election. The supplied account does not establish what voters will decide, or which competing claims deserve their confidence. It does offer a starting point for a difficult inquiry: what should people require of those who promise to protect them?
A promise of safety needs to remain open to challenge, including when it is popular. Otherwise, the people making it acquire a peculiar advantage. They can ask for authority on the strength of a danger while treating objections to their authority as indifference to that same danger. The argument becomes very hard to escape.
There is a serious objection here. Governments must sometimes act quickly, with incomplete information, and cannot submit every operational decision to public debate. People facing a threat may reasonably resent being offered a lecture on procedure when they need effective protection.
Yet urgency does not explain why power should become harder to question indefinitely. A decision may require confidentiality; the authority to make it still needs limits. And an election, however decisive, cannot answer every later question about what a government does.
This matters beyond the preferences of the winning voters. Government decisions reach people who opposed them, people too young to vote and people affected without having any electoral say. Their exposure to the consequences does not disappear because a majority has spoken.
For anyone trying to think honestly about living together, this creates an uncomfortable responsibility. We have to examine the powers we welcome when our preferred leaders hold them. Would we accept those same powers in the hands of someone we deeply distrust? If the answer is no, there is work to do before handing them over.