Article

The Power to Enforce Is Not Permission to Kill

15 November 2026

A person can break a rule without forfeiting their life. That ought to be an ordinary starting point for thinking about authority, yet it becomes strangely easy to lose sight of when the person is described through a border, a legal category or a supposed threat.

The Kurdistan Human Rights Network reports that Iranian border guards killed a Kurdish kolbar in Baneh. The information supplied here does not establish the circumstances of the killing, whether there was an immediate threat, or what justification the authorities may offer. It would be wrong to fill those gaps with a story that suits our expectations.

But uncertainty about an incident need not mean uncertainty about the burden carried by anyone who uses lethal force. The authority to enforce a boundary cannot, by itself, justify taking a life at that boundary. There must be a further justification, open to scrutiny. Otherwise the existence of a rule becomes its own permission for violence.

There is a serious objection here. Border guards may face danger. Decisions can have to be made quickly, with incomplete information, and an observer reading a report afterwards has time the person on the ground may never have had. Any honest examination must allow for that.

Allowing for it does not settle the matter. Danger cannot become a standing explanation which relieves an institution of examining a particular death. If we accept that power sometimes needs to act before everything is known, we have an even stronger reason to insist that its actions can be questioned afterwards.

This reaches beyond borders. Living together requires rules, but also the ability to recognise when our loyalty to a rule has displaced attention to the human being caught beneath it. Compliance is a poor measure of whose death deserves explanation.

For those reading this report, the responsible response is to keep its limits visible while refusing to let those limits make the death disappear. Seek fuller reporting. Ask what evidence supports any account of necessity. Leave room for facts that complicate an initial judgement.

A demand for an explanation is not a verdict. Authorities should not require us to deliver a verdict before they owe one.