Article

The person who changes their mind

Reconsidering a belief can be a sign of integrity rather than weakness.

15 October 2026

There is a peculiar ceremony in public life whenever somebody changes their mind. Old statements are retrieved, dates compared and a verdict prepared. The person is either accused of inconsistency or praised for finally seeing what everyone else already knew. Very little curiosity is shown about how the change occurred.

Of course, people sometimes reverse their positions for convenience. A new audience or a threatened career can make yesterday’s certainty look rather less attractive. We ought to examine those motives when they matter. But the possibility of opportunism should not make every change of mind suspect. If no one may revise a conviction without humiliation, we have given people a strong incentive to defend error.

An open philosophy depends on a more demanding kind of honesty. It asks us to say what we believe, why we believe it and what might cause us to reconsider. That last part is uncomfortable. It means admitting, before an argument begins, that our present understanding is incomplete.

This does not require treating every opinion as equally convincing. Evidence differs in quality. Experience can correct one assumption while leaving another intact. Some moral commitments deserve deep persistence. A person should be able to explain why a principle matters and why abandoning it would have consequences. Intellectual openness is not an obligation to drift wherever the loudest voice points.

It helps to separate the thing we value from the explanation we currently give for it. Someone may care deeply about human dignity while changing their account of which laws or institutions best protect it. The value can endure through serious disagreement about methods. That distinction makes conversation possible without requiring anyone to pretend differences are trivial.

The Continuance is intended to be carried forward by people who can examine it. It would be a poor inheritance if its founder’s first answers became immune to correction. Future participants will encounter circumstances I have never imagined. They ought to have the freedom, and the responsibility, to respond intelligently.

Perhaps we could learn to ask a different question when somebody changes their mind: what did you discover? The answer may reveal courage, confusion, new evidence or a calculation we should challenge. At least it begins with inquiry.

I would rather belong to a community in which people occasionally say ‘I was wrong’ than one in which everybody remembers their lines perfectly.

Explore The Continuance