Being willing to risk arrest does not make a person right. But when people apparently accept that risk simply by holding a sign, there is something to examine beyond whether the police have correctly applied the law. We need to ask what room remains for people to challenge the law’s own moral judgement.
The Guardian reports that almost 140 people were arrested at a demonstration outside the US embassy in London against the proscription of Palestine Action. Some held signs reading: “I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action.” The report attributes to the Metropolitan Police the allegation that demonstrators had gathered deliberately to commit an offence. The supplied account does not establish the circumstances of each arrest or what will follow.
That leaves an important distinction unresolved. A person may knowingly break a law because they reject its authority in that instance. Describing their intention to offend may be legally relevant, yet it does little to answer their objection. Their objection is precisely that this expression of support should not be criminal.
There is a difficulty here for protesters too. Support for an organisation can mean more than its speaker intends. Someone may mean solidarity with a cause, while another person reasonably hears approval of the organisation’s methods. Conscience does not relieve us of responsibility for what our words communicate. Opposing suffering does not settle every question about the means used in that opposition.
Still, a society needs ways to distinguish those meanings rather than allowing the broadest interpretation to swallow them all. Where expression is criminalised, the justification should be specific enough for an ordinary person to examine and contest. Invoking the existence of a ban cannot, by itself, justify the ban. Otherwise the discussion becomes circular, with handcuffs.
For anyone trying to think seriously about how we live together, the uncomfortable task is to apply that demand even when the speaker’s allegiance troubles us. We cannot make freedom to challenge authority depend entirely on whether we approve of the challenge.
The practical consequence is a responsibility on both sides: protesters should explain what they support, including where their support ends; public authorities should explain why those distinctions are insufficient, if they believe they are. People facing arrest deserve an answer that addresses the substance of their dissent. “You knew it was illegal” answers a different question.