For someone seeking justice against a powerful opponent, the most important question may be whether anyone will hear the case at all. A right can exist on paper while the possibility of exercising it quietly disappears. No declaration needs to be withdrawn. It is enough to make the institution responsible for hearing the claim unable, or afraid, to proceed.
Al Jazeera reports that the International Criminal Court, which is subject to US sanctions, has won the Sakharov Prize, the European Union’s highest human rights award. That places recognition and pressure alongside one another. The report’s headline alone cannot establish the merits of particular proceedings or the full effects of the sanctions. It does, however, offer a reason to examine how readily we accept institutions when their work becomes inconvenient.
There is little difficulty in supporting justice while imagining ourselves among those it protects. The difficulty arrives when its scrutiny reaches someone we support, or when a judgement unsettles a version of events around which we have arranged our loyalties. At that point, independence can begin to look remarkably like interference.
This does not mean a court deserves unquestioning loyalty. Courts exercise power over human beings. Their procedures, reasoning and limits need examination, especially by people who believe their work matters. An award cannot settle whether a decision is sound, any more than sanctions can establish that it is unsound.
But criticism carries a responsibility of its own. Challenging a court’s reasoning leaves open the possibility of an answer. Making its work impossible can close that possibility for everyone, including people whose claims have attracted no public attention.
The uncomfortable obligation is to preserve a process through which our own certainty might be challenged. That applies to governments, but it also reaches into ordinary life: the exceptions we make for friends, the evidence we dismiss because of who presents it, the misconduct we suddenly find complicated when our side is implicated.
A prize may recognise an institution. The harder commitment comes afterwards, when a case is unpopular, the reasoning requires patient attention, and defending the possibility of a fair hearing brings no applause from the people whose approval we usually seek.