A person facing police authority should not have to win an argument about their own worth before their rights matter. Yet this is where the difficulty begins: it is easy to defend someone we believe to be innocent, considerably harder when we suspect they have done something dreadful.
Punch Newspapers reports that Delta’s Commissioner of Police has called on officers to respect human rights. The instruction matters. It does not, by itself, establish how officers behave or whether anything will change. It does offer an occasion to examine what we expect a right to do when someone has power over another person.
If protection depends on an officer finding someone credible, respectable or sufficiently cooperative, it becomes a favour. The person exercising authority gets to decide who qualifies. Rights place a limit on that discretion, including when the person concerned is difficult, dishonest or guilty.
There is an understandable objection. Police officers may have to act quickly, with incomplete information, in circumstances where hesitation carries risks. An account of rights that ignores danger will tell us little about how to act within it.
But uncertainty also strengthens the case for restraint. The less we know, the more room there is for an error that another human being will have to live with. Urgency may justify a particular intervention; it cannot make every intervention justified. The difficult work lies in preserving that distinction under pressure, then allowing decisions to be examined afterwards.
This reaches beyond policing. Living together requires us to give people powers we would not permit everyone to exercise. We authorise them to restrain us, judge us and sometimes deprive us of liberty. We cannot sensibly make that arrangement depend on their always being wise or our always appearing innocent.
An evolving philosophy of human life has to leave room for correction, including correction of the people entrusted with enforcing the rules. That means asking practical questions about whether a person can challenge their treatment, and whether anyone with power must answer.
A reminder about human rights is a beginning. Its value will be found in what happens when an officer is convinced someone does not deserve the patience, restraint or protection those rights require.