Article

Responsibility Requires More Than a Name

27 October 2026

Someone speaking under their own name may be risking very little. Someone withholding it may be risking their livelihood if they are recognised. Before making visibility a condition of public speech, we ought to consider how differently that condition falls on different people.

The Guardian reports that Liberal MP Dan Tehan has raised concerns about anonymous accounts and inflammatory political discussion. He argues that people should put their names to their words, while acknowledging uncertainty about whether anonymity heightens the problem.

There is something reasonable in the desire behind this. A person subjected to abuse should not have to argue with an endless succession of disposable identities. The freedom to speak becomes a peculiar freedom when one person can repeatedly attack another and disappear whenever an answer is demanded.

But attaching a name does not resolve the ethical difficulty. A false accusation remains false when delivered by an identifiable person. A warning about wrongdoing deserves examination even when its author is afraid to sign it. Identity tells us something about who is speaking; it cannot do the work of deciding whether they should be believed.

Consider an employee wishing to describe misconduct by someone who controls their income. Requiring a public name might make the statement easier to challenge. It might also ensure that the statement is never made. Any proposal to make speech more responsible has to reckon with the responsible speech it could prevent.

The harder task is to distinguish protection from impunity. That requires attention to conduct: whether a person supplies grounds for an allegation, corrects an error, threatens someone, or keeps pursuing them after being challenged. These are questions we can ask of a named politician and an anonymous account alike. Public standing should offer no exemption from them.

For those reading, there is a responsibility here too. We should be slower to circulate claims merely because they arrive from someone recognisable, and slower to dismiss uncomfortable evidence because its source needs protection.

Requiring everyone to show their face has an appealing simplicity. It leaves unanswered what happens when the face belongs to someone powerful, and the person answering them has rather more to lose.