Article

Progress Must Leave Room for People to Refuse

11 November 2026

For someone whose home or livelihood may be affected by a development project, being invited to welcome the future is a peculiar kind of invitation. What happens if they decline? The answer tells us something important about the future being offered.

Peace Brigades International-Canada has raised the implications for human rights defenders of what its report describes as a new Canada–Philippines free trade agreement, alongside the Luzon Economic Corridor. The supplied reporting does not establish the agreement’s precise status or demonstrate particular harms arising from either initiative. It does, however, bring a serious ethical problem into view: how much freedom remains for people who challenge an economic future that governments have already decided to pursue?

An economic plan is a prediction about what will improve people’s lives. However impressive its supporting documents, it remains fallible. People living with its consequences may notice something its designers have missed. They may also disagree with the designers about what counts as an improvement.

That disagreement deserves more than a consultation exercise whose outcome changes nothing.

There is a reasonable objection here. Shared life requires decisions, and no infrastructure project or trade arrangement can secure everyone’s consent. Giving every objection the force of a veto could prevent changes that many people urgently need.

Yet a decision can proceed without making opposition dangerous or futile. The important distinction is between losing an argument and losing the practical freedom to keep making it. Human rights defenders need to be able to question decisions, gather evidence and support affected people after the announcements have been made. Otherwise, public participation expires just when experience begins to test the promises.

This matters beyond any single agreement. We often treat commitment as a virtue and revision as an embarrassment. Institutions acquire reputations, careers become attached to projects, and changing course starts to look like admitting failure. The people asking awkward questions then become inconvenient reminders that the plan was never certain.

A society capable of learning needs those reminders. Before celebrating the benefits promised by an agreement or corridor, its supporters should explain what could make them reconsider, and how someone with little money or influence could get that evidence heard. The answer needs to survive the signing ceremony.