Article

Political Freedom Requires Room to Remain an Opponent

7 November 2026

A person should be able to lose an election and still feel safe walking home. They should also be able to support the losing side, criticise the winning one, or decide that neither deserves their loyalty. Without that ordinary security, political freedom becomes a permission that someone stronger can withdraw.

The Statesman reports that Bengal’s human rights body has directed police to curb political violence. The supplied report does not establish the circumstances of particular incidents or what action followed. It does, however, give us reason to examine a responsibility that reaches beyond any single political dispute: protecting people whose convictions others find intolerable.

There is a temptation to treat political violence as an excess of belief, as though people have simply become too committed to their cause. That explanation lets something important escape examination. Commitment need not produce violence. The dangerous step is deciding that commitment grants authority over somebody else’s safety.

Once that step is accepted, almost any threat can acquire a respectable justification. The cause is urgent. The opponents are dangerous. Restraint would help the wrong people. Each argument asks the threatened person to bear the cost of someone else’s certainty.

Yet protection brings its own difficulty. A direction to police is only as useful as the fairness with which it is carried out. Preventing violence cannot become a reason to suppress peaceful opposition. Nor should impartiality mean pretending every incident has identical causes or equal responsibility on all sides. Evidence still matters. So does distinguishing a person expressing an unwelcome opinion from a person making a threat.

This is where an open philosophy of living together has practical work to do. We can question inherited beliefs for years and still fail the immediate test of allowing another person to question ours. A society needs ways for disagreement to continue without requiring anyone to surrender their physical security.

That has consequences for supporters as well as public authorities. When intimidation appears to benefit our preferred side, we have to decide whether we will excuse it. Waiting until every allegation is settled before making a factual judgement is reasonable; withholding opposition to intimidation until we know the target’s political allegiance is something else.

An opponent who has been frightened into silence has not changed their mind. Whatever advantage that silence brings, it leaves the underlying disagreement unresolved and makes honest political life harder for the next person who wishes to speak.