A prison sentence takes time from a human life, and no later explanation can give that time back. That ought to make us particularly demanding when the justification is national security. The importance of protecting people cannot relieve a government of explaining what it is protecting them from, or why a particular punishment is necessary.
The International Service for Human Rights reports that the UN human rights chief has raised concerns over harsh national security sentences in connection with Hong Kong and Macao. That reported concern does not, by itself, establish the circumstances of individual cases or settle their merits. It does give us reason to examine a problem that reaches beyond any single jurisdiction: how can people challenge the exercise of power when power invokes their safety as its defence?
There is a serious objection here. Governments have responsibilities that cannot be discharged through endless discussion. Threats can be real; waiting for harm may be an appalling failure. Anyone arguing for restraint must allow for the possibility that intervention is necessary.
But necessity needs examination precisely because it is such a powerful justification. If the words “national security” are allowed to end an argument, almost any severity can become difficult to question. A responsible demand for evidence can then be treated as a failure to understand the danger.
For an open philosophy concerned with how we live together, the deeper issue is our capacity to correct ourselves. Every human institution is capable of error. A society still has to make decisions, sometimes urgently, while preserving ways to discover that those decisions were wrong. Punishment makes this obligation especially acute because the person bearing the cost may have very little power to secure a hearing.
This has consequences for ordinary public judgement too. We should resist deciding whether scrutiny is welcome according to whether we sympathise with the people being scrutinised. Ask what conduct has been established, whether the punishment is proportionate, and whether a challenge can receive a meaningful hearing.
Those demands may be inconvenient when fear is high. Yet fear is exactly when a mistaken decision can acquire momentum, defenders and years of someone else’s life.