Article

Human Rights Must Leave Room for People We Distrust

20 October 2026

It is easy enough to defend someone whose account of the world resembles our own. The difficulty begins when the person asking to be heard holds beliefs we consider foolish, offensive or dangerous. Then the right we thought we supported starts acquiring conditions.

Vindobona.org reports on an OSCE human rights conference in Warsaw, describing it as Europe’s largest. That description tells us something about its scale, though it cannot tell us what the gathering will achieve. Its subject invites a harder consideration: how much protection are we prepared to give people whose influence we would rather diminish?

A useful starting proposition is that a person should not have to win our approval before being protected from abuse. Otherwise, rights become rewards for acceptable membership, and whoever controls the definition of acceptable holds a considerable weapon.

This has consequences for an open philosophy concerned with how people live together. We cannot seriously invite people to examine inherited beliefs while making disagreement a reason to withdraw their standing as people. Revision requires somewhere to stand while the argument is taking place. Someone who fears humiliation, exclusion or punishment may learn to repeat the approved answer without reconsidering anything at all.

There is an obvious complication. Beliefs can lead to actions that harm others. Allowing someone to speak does not oblige anyone to supply an audience, and protecting a person does not place their conduct beyond challenge. The difficult work lies in making those distinctions carefully, especially when anger makes a sweeping judgement feel satisfying.

In practice, this means asking what someone has actually done, what evidence supports an accusation, and whether they have a meaningful opportunity to answer it. These can seem laborious requirements when we are certain of our own judgement. Certainty is precisely when they matter.

Conferences can provide a place for such questions. Their size alone cannot answer them. Much depends on what happens afterwards, including in ordinary settings where nobody is drafting a declaration: a workplace dispute, a community meeting, a family argument in which one person has become easy to dismiss.

We might begin there, with the person we would least like to hear from, and examine whether our reasons for refusing them would still seem fair if someone applied them to us.