A pupil should be able to disagree with a teacher without fearing that the disagreement will cost them fair treatment. That is a small enough proposition to fit inside a classroom, yet it contains a considerable part of the difficulty of living together.
The Post Register reports that Kerry Thomas, of Rigby High School, has been named Idaho Human Rights Educator of the Year. The reported recognition offers an occasion to consider what such education should make possible. The headline alone cannot tell us how Thomas teaches, and it would be unfair to supply an imagined classroom on that basis.
There is, however, a worthwhile argument to pursue: education about human rights ought to help people understand the limits of their own authority, including when they are certain they are right.
It is relatively comfortable to defend someone whose judgement we admire. The difficulty arrives with the person who is mistaken, irritating, perhaps openly hostile to something we value. Their entitlement to fair treatment cannot depend on becoming more agreeable first. Otherwise, whoever holds power gets to decide which personalities qualify.
That presents a real problem for a teacher. A classroom needs boundaries. One pupil’s freedom to speak cannot mean that everyone else must endure intimidation, and an obligation to hear disagreement does not make every claim equally sound. Teachers must still correct errors and intervene when conduct prevents others from learning.
But there is a difference worth preserving between challenging what a pupil says and making their standing in the room conditional on saying the approved thing. The distinction requires judgement. A poster on the wall cannot make it for us.
For an evolving philosophy concerned with how people live together, this reaches beyond schools. We inherit convictions, revise some, cling to others, and sometimes acquire enough authority to impose them. We need to ask what happens to the person who refuses to follow us.
An award can recognise an educator. The harder public commitment is to give educators time and support to practise this difficult judgement, while remaining willing to question how they exercise it. Pupils will learn something from the answer, whatever the lesson plan says.