Someone who has been wronged may have very little to offer a government. No useful connections, no audience large enough to cause embarrassment, perhaps not even a vote. Whether that person can still obtain protection is a serious test of political life. It is also a test of the rest of us, who may prefer public attention to remain on problems closer to home.
Eurasia Review reports that Human Rights Watch has called on Lula to prioritise human rights in a new term in Brazil. That reported appeal does not, by itself, establish what his administration will do. It does invite us to examine what we mean when we ask a government to make rights a priority.
The word can sound reassuringly practical, as though rights occupy a place on a list which a sufficiently industrious administration will eventually reach. Yet some obligations must govern the making of the list itself. A government cannot reasonably ask people to accept avoidable mistreatment until protecting them becomes politically convenient.
There is a difficulty here. Public resources are finite. Protection requires functioning institutions, people capable of doing the work, and decisions between needs that can all be urgent. Calling something a right does not conjure the means to secure it. A serious appeal must leave room for that difficulty, otherwise moral certainty becomes a substitute for doing anything useful.
But scarcity also demands an explanation. Whose protection is being delayed? Who bears the consequences? Can those affected challenge the decision, or are they simply expected to endure it? These are practical questions about how power is exercised.
For those of us watching politics, the uncomfortable consequence is that our preferred government needs scrutiny too. Affection for a leader can become an advance payment of forgiveness, extended before we know who will pay for the failures.
An open philosophy of living together has to remain open to unwelcome evidence, including evidence about people we support. Otherwise our concern for human rights quietly acquires an electoral condition: everyone deserves protection, provided their claim does not inconvenience our side.