For someone whose freedom depends on a government’s decision, that government’s account of its own goodness is of limited use. A proud national story offers little protection if the person making the decision can quietly decide that this particular life falls outside it.
The supplied fragment, attributed to The Washington Post, describes Navi Pillay appealing to the United States to resume a role protecting human rights. It is incomplete: its claim about a Nobel award and its reference to a subsequent American action cannot be established from the material provided. The appeal itself nevertheless opens a worthwhile question about what we ask of powerful countries when we ask them to return to their better selves.
There is a practical reason to make that appeal. People often respond more readily to an obligation they recognise than to an accusation. Reminding a country of its professed commitments can give its citizens grounds on which to challenge their government. A promise made publicly is something others can hold you to.
But the word “return” carries a difficulty. It can invite us to imagine a morally settled past, with virtue waiting there intact for us to recover. Then the argument becomes a dispute about national reputation, and the people whose rights are at stake have to wait while everyone argues over the portrait.
An open philosophy of how we live together must leave room to revise inherited accounts of who we are. That includes the flattering ones. Otherwise, responsibility becomes strangely conditional: we will protect you because doing so confirms our identity, and we may struggle to hear you when your suffering challenges it.
This does not require abandoning national pride. It requires allowing evidence to disturb it.
The practical consequence is demanding. A commitment to human rights must remain available to people who embarrass us, disagree with us or cannot repay our help. Citizens need to be able to examine particular decisions without treating criticism as betrayal. Governments should expect their promises to be tested precisely where keeping them becomes inconvenient.
Those are the cases in which someone waiting for protection discovers what the promise is worth.