Article

Distance Should Not Decide Who Is Owed a Hearing

4 November 2026

Someone who brings an account of suffering to a public institution is asking for more than permission to speak. They are asking whether what happened to them can place an obligation on anyone else. For people living outside their country of origin, that question has an additional difficulty: responsibility can become remarkably elusive when it has a border to cross.

ACP reports that Congolese diaspora victims of atrocities have referred a matter to a National Human Rights Commission, in a story concerning the Democratic Republic of the Congo and France. The reported referral does not itself establish responsibility for the alleged acts, and the information supplied does not establish what response will follow.

Even within those limits, there is something worth examining. Moving elsewhere should not weaken a person’s claim to have serious harm properly considered. Yet the practical distance between suffering and an institution able to address it can be considerable. A right may remain perfectly intact on paper while becoming almost impossible to exercise.

There is an important objection here. Institutions cannot treat every account as a settled finding. Evidence matters; so do fair procedures and the rights of those accused. A philosophy concerned with how we live together cannot simply abandon those protections when an account is distressing.

But a demand for evidence needs a process through which evidence can actually be heard. Otherwise, caution becomes a respectable way of ensuring that nothing ever reaches the point of examination. Taking someone seriously requires neither automatic belief nor a promise of the outcome they seek. It requires a genuine possibility that what they bring could change what the institution does.

That distinction matters well beyond this report. When we say that human rights belong to everyone, we accept an awkward practical burden. We have to consider who can reach the bodies meant to protect them, who understands the procedure, and what happens when responsibility is passed elsewhere.

For those seeking a hearing, a referral is still only a beginning. The serious test comes afterwards: whether there is a route through the institution, or merely an entrance.