Article

Depending on Care Must Not Mean Surrendering Your Voice

17 October 2026

Someone who depends on other people for care may also depend on them to make a complaint possible. There is a difficulty here that good intentions alone cannot resolve. How freely can you challenge the person whose help you will need again tomorrow?

Human Rights Watch has reported on an abusive care facility in Thailand, raising wider concerns. The supplied reporting does not establish the circumstances of individual residents or the response of the authorities, so those details cannot responsibly be filled in. But the report gives us reason to examine a dangerous assumption: that placing someone in care settles the question of whether they are being cared for.

It settles very little by itself. A person has entered a relationship in which somebody else may have considerable power over daily life. The ethical question continues after admission, through all the ordinary hours that relatives, inspectors and the public do not see.

Care necessarily involves judgement. Sometimes a carer must make a decision that the person receiving care dislikes, perhaps urgently. It would be dishonest to pretend that respecting someone always means agreeing with them. Yet this difficulty can become a remarkably convenient shelter for authority. Once disagreement is treated as evidence that a person cannot judge their own circumstances, almost anything they say can be dismissed.

A workable safeguard must therefore allow care itself to be questioned. Someone receiving support needs a way to speak to a person who is not dependent on the institution’s approval. A complaint need not be accepted as proven to deserve a hearing. Nor should someone have to become unusually articulate or persistent before their account matters.

This has implications beyond any single facility. When we arrange care for another person, our responsibility cannot end with finding a place willing to take them. We need to ask how they will remain able to object, and who will listen if their account becomes inconvenient.

Dependence is part of human life. Many of us will experience it, sometimes after years of imagining ourselves entirely self-sufficient. We should be wary of arrangements whose safety depends on the dependent person being fortunate enough to encounter kindness. There must be somewhere for them to turn when kindness fails.