For someone trying to make their income last until the next payday, a defence of democracy can sound strangely remote. There is the shopping to pay for. There is whatever has broken and cannot yet be replaced. Being told to worry about institutions may feel like being given another responsibility by people who have fewer immediate worries.
That is a difficulty any serious democratic argument has to face.
The Guardian’s supplied report on the 2026 US midterm elections describes voters identifying both the economy and the state of democracy as crucial concerns as they decide the direction of Congress. The summary does not establish an electoral outcome. It does, however, put two anxieties alongside each other which political debate too easily separates.
Democracy has to be worth something to people whose lives are difficult. Yet its value cannot sensibly be measured only by whether the present government has made them more comfortable. If that becomes the entire test, the freedom to remove a government can come to seem expendable whenever someone promises a sufficiently convincing rescue.
The objection is obvious: constitutional safeguards do not pay the bills. Quite so. A political system that repeatedly asks people to protect it while appearing indifferent to their circumstances should expect a poor reception. But the ability to challenge decisions matters especially when those decisions leave you struggling. Economic insecurity makes that ability more necessary, even as it can make patience with democratic processes harder to sustain.
There is also the question of what those exercising power choose to attend to. In the same report, the Guardian attributes to Trump a Truth Social post attacking Fox News contributor Jessica Tarlov’s voice and intelligence.
An insult cannot tell us everything about a presidency. It does show how readily public attention can be drawn away from claims that require an answer towards a person who can be ridiculed.
People disagreeing about their future need more than permission to speak. They need some reasonable expectation that what they say will be considered. That expectation weakens when humiliation becomes an accepted substitute for response.
No voter should have to pretend that material hardship is secondary. Equally, anyone offering relief should remain answerable to those who doubt the offer, question its cost or find themselves worse off afterwards. The promise of a better life cannot be allowed to cancel the means of challenging a broken promise.