Article

Custody Does Not Give Authority Over Every Human Need

30 October 2026

A woman giving birth is doing something no sentence, uniform or locked door can do on her behalf. Her body has its own demands. If she is also a prisoner, the institution holding her must decide whether it can respond to those demands without treating every concession to them as a loss of control.

Human Rights Watch has called for women never to give birth in shackles. The supplied reporting does not establish the circumstances of a particular case, so there is no basis here for assigning motives to individual staff or describing what happened in a delivery room. The ethical issue is substantial enough without adding an imagined scene.

Taking responsibility for someone’s custody creates obligations that cannot be discharged simply by keeping them confined. The more thoroughly an institution controls a person’s choices, the greater its responsibility for needs that person can no longer meet independently. Someone who cannot leave, seek another provider or decide who accompanies her has very little room to correct the institution’s failures.

Security is a real responsibility too. Staff may have to consider risks that people outside the institution do not know about. That deserves serious attention. Yet “security” cannot serve as a complete explanation merely because it is spoken by someone with authority. A restraint requires justification in the circumstances in which it is used. Its familiarity within a prison does not settle its appropriateness during childbirth.

There is an uncomfortable habit beneath this: allowing a category to do our thinking. Once someone is a prisoner, it becomes possible to regard every ordinary human claim as a request for special treatment. Pain, privacy and bodily vulnerability must then plead for exceptions to a rule that should have taken them into account from the beginning.

An evolving philosophy of living together has to examine that habit, including when the person affected attracts little public sympathy. We cannot make humane treatment depend on whether we approve of someone’s past.

The practical consequence belongs in the design of institutions, their rules and the decisions staff are expected to make. If a woman in labour must persuade an institution that her immediate bodily needs matter, something has already gone wrong in how that institution understands its responsibility.