Article

Belief Should Not Require Another Person’s Silence

19 October 2026

A writer who must consider whether an imagined scene could bring a police investigation has acquired a second task alongside writing: anticipating what somebody else may regard as intolerable. Eventually, that calculation can enter the work before a sentence reaches the page.

Human Rights Watch reports that an Indonesian author faces a blasphemy investigation over short stories. The reported headline alone does not establish the content of those stories or the circumstances of the investigation. It does, however, give us reason to examine the demand beneath blasphemy enforcement: that certain beliefs should be protected from forms of expression their defenders find unacceptable.

There is a serious difficulty here for any philosophy that remains open to revision. We cannot honestly invite people to examine inherited beliefs while allowing the possibility of punishment to govern what they may discover or say. Permission to question means little if it expires at the point where questioning becomes uncomfortable.

Religious offence can be deeply felt. A story may touch something bound up with a person’s family, their understanding of death, or the way they have endured suffering. Dismissing that attachment as foolish would be a poor beginning to any conversation about living together.

Yet the depth of an attachment cannot, by itself, give its holder authority over another person’s imagination. Otherwise, the more intensely a belief is held, the less freely anyone else may examine it. Conviction becomes a means of setting the boundaries of somebody else’s thought.

Writers still have responsibilities. Fiction can be cruel, lazy or deliberately demeaning. Readers can object, argue, refuse to buy it and explain what it gets wrong. Threats and incitement require their own scrutiny. None of that removes the need to distinguish harm to a person from an affront to a belief.

For The Continuance, as an evolving philosophical inquiry, this is a practical test of openness. It is easy to welcome questions whose answers leave our own assumptions intact. The harder work begins when somebody writes something we wish they had never thought.

At that point, we have choices about our own conduct. We can challenge the work closely and forcefully. Reaching for the machinery of criminal investigation is a very different choice, with consequences for people who have yet to write a word.