A person may remain silent because they agree, because they are tired, or because speaking would cost them more than they can afford. From a distance, those silences can look much the same. Anyone claiming to govern with public consent has a responsibility to distinguish between them. There is also an obvious temptation not to look too closely.
CTV News reports that a UN human rights expert has described Nicaragua’s leadership as a dictatorship. The supplied reporting does not establish the detailed basis for that assessment, so it would be wrong to manufacture an account of individual lives beneath it. But the assessment brings a precise ethical problem into view: what does agreement mean when people cannot safely withdraw it?
A government cannot reasonably treat public approval as evidence of its legitimacy while making disapproval dangerous. The conditions under which people speak are part of what their words mean. A declaration of loyalty made without a tolerable alternative tells us very little about loyalty.
The difficult objection is that societies need stability. They cannot renegotiate every decision indefinitely, and disagreement does not make someone right. Governments must sometimes act despite fierce opposition.
Yet the authority to make a decision need not include the authority to close the argument. People can be required to obey a law while retaining the freedom to challenge it, organise against it and seek its replacement. That distinction leaves room for the possibility that those governing have made a mistake. Removing it asks everyone else to bear the consequences of power’s certainty.
An evolving philosophy of how we live together has to take this seriously, including when scrutiny becomes inconvenient to its own ideas. Inviting questions achieves little if belonging depends on arriving at the approved answer.
None of this makes a family, a workplace or a philosophical community equivalent to a state. The differences in power and consequence are enormous. Still, there is something worth examining wherever agreement is celebrated: what happens to the person who changes their mind?
The burden should not fall entirely on that person to become braver. Those with the power to punish refusal have the greater responsibility to make it possible. Otherwise, they may spend years listening to agreement they have made impossible to trust.