Article

A Right Should Not Depend on Finding a Champion

21 October 2026

Someone trying to exercise a right may first have to understand a letter they cannot make sense of, challenge a decision they have been told is final, or risk upsetting somebody who has considerable power over their life. In those circumstances, being told that everyone has rights can be a rather lonely reassurance.

A society needs to ask how much courage, knowledge and spare time it requires people to possess before its promises become usable.

QLS Proctor reports that a CLC is vying for a national human rights award. That is the extent of the event detail available here; it does not establish an outcome or tell us which work is being considered. But the prospect of recognition offers a useful occasion to examine what we celebrate when we celebrate the defence of rights.

There is good reason to recognise people who help others obtain a hearing. Their work can matter enormously to the person who would otherwise have given up. The complication is that admiration can allow us to stop thinking too soon. We praise the person who makes a difficult system navigable and leave the difficulty itself undisturbed.

Some difficulty is unavoidable. Competing claims need examination, evidence needs testing, and a fair decision will not always be a quick one. Simplifying everything is no guarantee of justice. Even so, complexity becomes ethically suspect when the institution can manage it comfortably while the person whose life is affected cannot.

For an evolving philosophy concerned with how we live together, this is a practical test of responsibility. When we create a procedure, we also create demands on whoever must use it. We should be prepared to examine those demands, including the ones that seem perfectly reasonable from behind a desk.

An award can honour valuable work. It cannot settle whether the people needing that work were asked to overcome obstacles we had the power to remove. Whoever receives the recognition, that unfinished business remains with the institutions making the rules, and with those of us willing to accept them.