Article

A philosophy should be allowed to grow up

An open philosophy ought to welcome new evidence, disagreement and questions it cannot yet answer.

13 October 2026

There is something odd about an idea that claims to help people understand life and then refuses to learn anything new about it. The world changes. Our knowledge changes. We discover errors, meet people whose experiences unsettle our assumptions and find better questions to ask. A philosophy that cannot respond to those things risks becoming a museum of its own beginnings.

I can understand the appeal of certainty. It is comforting to possess a complete account of how things are and how everybody ought to behave. Doubt can feel like weakness, especially when you have committed years to an idea. Yet certainty has a price. It can turn disagreement into disloyalty and curiosity into something that has to be defended.

An open philosophy should be able to survive somebody saying, 'I don't think that part is right.' Better still, it should invite the question. If an argument is sound, examination can strengthen it. If the argument fails, we have learned something worth knowing. Protecting the argument from scrutiny protects neither truth nor the people who depend on it.

This does not mean having no principles. A person who changes their beliefs with every passing headline is not necessarily thoughtful. There is value in commitments that are difficult to live by and worth returning to. The point is to understand why we hold them and whether they continue to withstand experience.

The same principle applies to founders. A philosophy may begin with one person's writing, but it should never require that person to have the final word on every question. If the work has any real value, other people will test it against circumstances its founder never encountered. They will extend it, argue with it and sometimes correct it. That is how an idea acquires a life beyond its author.

Of course, openness is messy. People disagree. They interpret the same words differently. Somebody asks a question you thought had been settled years ago. There may be no convenient vote that resolves everything. I would rather live with that inconvenience than pretend human experience can be locked into a finished instruction manual.

The Continuance is intended to be approached in that spirit: something to consider, test, practise, question and help develop. Nobody needs to surrender their judgement in order to take part. A thoughtful disagreement can contribute more than a hundred polite nods.

We can keep what proves valuable. We can reconsider what does not. We can remain responsible for the consequences of what we believe and do. And we can listen when somebody else's life provides an answer different from our own.

Perhaps the best sign that a philosophy is alive is that its participants still have questions. I hope they always do.

Explore The Continuance