Article

A Job Offer Begins Before the Interview

6 November 2026

Someone applying for a job is deciding how to spend part of a life. The employer is entitled to ask whether that person can do the work. The applicant ought to be able to ask whether the work can support the life they have. Leaving the salary undisclosed makes one of those enquiries unnecessarily difficult.

BBC Business reports that firms are being urged to include salaries in job adverts ahead of a new law. The government argues that the change will help jobseekers and could help prevent pay discrimination. Those are the reported aims; whether the measure achieves them will depend on its detail and on what employers actually do.

There is a more immediate ethical proposition worth considering: if we invite someone to commit their time to a decision, we owe them the information we already hold that could reasonably change their answer.

An application may require thought, preparation and the awkward business of imagining a different future. An employer asking for that effort while withholding the proposed pay leaves the applicant to discover, perhaps much later, whether the opportunity was ever workable. No deliberate cruelty is required. An inherited business habit can be inconsiderate without anyone having set out to be inconsiderate.

Of course, a salary may depend on experience or the eventual scope of a role. Publishing a figure cannot settle every question of fairness, and a range so broad that it tells the applicant almost nothing would satisfy the appearance of openness rather better than its purpose. But uncertainty can be explained. An employer can say what remains undecided and why. That is a different relationship from simply expecting the applicant to proceed without knowing.

The discrimination argument also needs care. Visibility alone cannot establish that people doing comparable work are treated fairly. It can, however, give them something concrete to question. A promise of fairness is difficult to examine when the relevant information remains private.

How people live together is shaped partly by these ordinary permissions: who may ask, who must disclose, whose time can be spent before the terms are clear. Publishing a salary asks an employer to accept that the person seeking work is making a choice too, and deserves enough information to decline before an interview ever takes place.