For someone asking the police for protection, delay can feel like abandonment. For someone wrongly suspected, the demand for swift action can become a threat. Any serious account of law enforcement has to make room for both people, including when public anger would prefer to forget one of them.
The Nation’s discussion of IGP Disu brings law enforcement and human rights into the question of Nigeria’s future. The supplied headline does not establish what changes have been proposed or achieved. It does, however, offer a useful starting point: what would make a promise of renewal meaningful to someone who has little influence over the people exercising power?
A change of leadership may create an opportunity. It cannot, by itself, answer that question. A person seeking protection should not have to depend on finding an unusually decent officer, just as someone facing suspicion should not have to hope that whoever questions them happens to be in a generous mood. Decency matters enormously. Depending on it as a substitute for dependable safeguards asks too much of the vulnerable.
There is a reasonable objection here. Police officers must sometimes act quickly, with incomplete information and the possibility of danger. Demanding perfect judgement would make useful action impossible.
But the case for scrutiny does not depend on believing that mistakes can be eliminated. It begins with accepting that they cannot. The greater the authority to intervene in another person’s life, the more important it becomes to explain a decision, examine a complaint and correct an error. An institution that treats challenge as disloyalty makes its own mistakes harder to discover.
This also asks something uncomfortable of the public. Supporting rights means accepting limits on what may be done to people we fear or dislike. It means resisting the satisfaction of a decisive response when we do not yet know whether the decision was justified.
A different future becomes credible when an ordinary person can question an official decision without needing a powerful friend to make the question safe. Whatever expectations gather around IGP Disu, that is a practical test worth keeping in view: can the person with the least leverage still get an answer?