Article

The Freedom to Leave Should Not Depend on Agreement

15 November 2026

Being prevented from travelling means that someone else gets to decide which parts of your life can proceed. A meeting, a conversation, the chance to speak where people might listen: all become conditional on permission. Whoever controls that permission acquires considerable power over the person asking for it.

DAWN, Democracy for the Arab World Now, reports that Israel has banned human rights defender Shawan Jabarin from travelling. The supplied report does not establish the grounds for the restriction or the means available to challenge it. Those details matter, and it would be irresponsible to supply them from assumption.

Even with that uncertainty, there is a question worth pursuing. When a state restricts someone’s movement, who should carry the burden of justification?

There is a temptation to begin by deciding whether we approve of the person concerned. We examine their affiliations, their arguments, perhaps their manner, and allow our sympathy to determine how much freedom seems reasonable. Yet a freedom distributed according to approval is a precarious thing. Everyone remains free until they become sufficiently inconvenient.

States do have responsibilities towards public safety. A restriction can sometimes be justified, and the description “human rights defender” cannot settle every factual dispute. But invoking security cannot settle it either. A reason needs evidence, a connection to the particular restriction and some meaningful possibility of being challenged. Otherwise the person affected is expected to answer a case they may have no practical way to contest.

For an evolving philosophy concerned with how people live together, this reaches beyond the conduct of governments. We also have to examine our willingness to accept coercion when it falls upon somebody whose views we dislike. That willingness helps make arbitrary power socially tolerable.

The useful response to DAWN’s report is therefore to seek the grounds for the reported ban and ask how they can be tested. Agreement with Jabarin is not a prerequisite for asking. Nor should he have to win public affection before the authority restricting his movement is expected to explain itself.