Article

Public Order Must Leave Room for Public Refusal

14 November 2026

For someone considering joining a protest, the possibility of force changes the decision before they have even left home. There is the cause itself, and then there is the calculation of what supporting it might cost. A society can formally permit dissent while making that calculation so frightening that permission becomes rather hollow.

Human Rights Watch has reported allegations of excessive force against protesters in Indonesia. The supplied reporting does not establish the circumstances of particular encounters or determine individual responsibility. Those limits matter. An allegation should not quietly become a finding simply because it supports an argument we find persuasive.

Yet uncertainty about an incident need not leave us uncertain about the responsibility attached to power. When public authorities use force, they should be required to explain its necessity and submit that explanation to scrutiny independent of themselves. Otherwise, the people whose conduct is being questioned also decide whether the question deserves an answer.

There is a serious complication here. Protest does not make every action taken within it harmless, and those responsible for public safety may face genuine danger. Protecting the freedom to protest cannot mean abandoning everyone else’s safety. But danger cannot serve as a general permission slip either. The justification for an intervention has to concern what was actually happening, rather than the inconvenience of opposition or a presumption that a crowd is guilty by association.

This matters beyond the people who attend demonstrations. If the practical lesson drawn from a protest is that speaking publicly may expose someone to unjustified force without meaningful recourse, silence begins to look sensible. Authorities may then mistake that silence for agreement. They lose access to truths people no longer feel safe enough to tell them.

Any philosophy concerned with how we live together has to leave room for refusal, including refusal expressed awkwardly, angrily or at an inconvenient moment. Living together does not require enjoying one another’s objections. It does require resisting the temptation to make obedience the price of safety.

The allegations in Indonesia require examination on their evidence. Those considering whether to protest should not have to wait for that examination before their safety counts.