Article

A Right Needs Somewhere to Be Heard

12 November 2026

For someone trying to challenge an abuse of power, the existence of a right is only the beginning. There is still the problem of getting a hearing, obtaining evidence, persuading somebody with authority to look at what happened. A right can remain intact on paper while the route to exercising it quietly disappears.

That is the concern worth examining in the report from Congressman Jim McGovern’s office that he and Jamie Raskin have condemned the Trump administration’s withdrawal from a human rights accountability mechanism. The supplied report does not establish the mechanism’s precise remit or the practical effects of withdrawal. It would be premature to claim that a particular person has lost a remedy. But the ethical issue deserves attention: what responsibility does a government retain when it leaves an arrangement through which its conduct can be questioned?

Participation alone proves very little. An institution can have an impressive title, hold meetings and produce documents without helping anyone who needs it. There is no virtue in preserving a useless process simply because its vocabulary sounds humane. Governments should be able to challenge institutions, including those concerned with human rights.

Yet criticism of a mechanism cannot, by itself, answer the person who needs one. If the existing arrangement is defective, where can that person now take their complaint? Who can examine it with sufficient independence? What happens when the government’s account and the complainant’s account disagree?

Those are practical questions, and any defence of withdrawal ought to reach them.

There is a temptation in political argument to settle everything at the level of allegiance. We trust the government, or we trust its critics, and then fit the institutional question around that preference. But arrangements for scrutiny have to survive changes in whom we trust. Otherwise, each election becomes an invitation to decide whose complaints deserve a hearing.

For an evolving philosophy of living together, this is a useful discipline: judge an arrangement partly from the position of someone who cannot command its attention. That does not settle whether this particular withdrawal is defensible. It does establish what a serious defence would need to explain. The person challenging power should not be left with fewer places to turn merely because the powerful have found the questioning objectionable.