When someone disappears, those who love them face an additional burden: keeping their absence visible to people whose lives have carried on. They must find ways to make the unanswered question remain somebody else’s responsibility. There is something profoundly wrong with making that persistence a condition of being heard.
The Robert & Ethel Kennedy Human Rights Center reports a discussion involving experts and families about the implications of what it describes as the first-ever referral of Mexico to the United Nations General Assembly over enforced disappearances. The supplied report does not establish what the referral will achieve. Its significance cannot responsibly be measured in advance.
But the involvement of families brings a difficult issue into view. How much work do we expect people to perform before their suffering becomes a public obligation?
We often admire persistence. In circumstances like these, that admiration deserves examining. Praising a family’s determination can become a comfortable substitute for asking why so much determination is required. Someone who keeps demanding an answer may be called courageous, while the arrangements that leave them having to demand it remain largely unquestioned.
Their resolve can be admirable and the burden intolerable. Both judgements belong in the same conversation.
There is a complication. Public institutions need evidence, procedures and limits on what they can claim to know. A family’s anguish cannot establish every fact, and an international referral cannot itself supply an answer about an individual disappearance. To suggest otherwise would offer hope on terms nobody has earned the right to promise.
Yet uncertainty about an outcome does not remove responsibility for the process. It makes the quality of that process more important. Families should be able to question institutions without becoming experts in institutional survival. Their right to an answer should not depend on their ability to attract attention, travel, speak publicly or continue campaigning when they are exhausted.
For an evolving philosophy concerned with how we live together, this is a practical test of what we mean by responsibility. Does it remain in place when the person asking for action has no more energy to ask?
Any judgement of this referral will eventually need to reach beyond the fact that a discussion took place. What work follows it? Who must do that work? And can a family step back from public campaigning without finding that everyone else has stepped back too?