Article

Justice Must Be Answerable for Its Own Methods

5 November 2026

Someone who has suffered a grave wrong may have to describe it again to people who were nowhere near it. Those people will ask for dates, evidence, distinctions. There is something painful about that distance. There is also something necessary in it, because the power to judge another human being cannot safely rest on the strength of anyone’s conviction alone.

INSIGHT EU MONITORING reports that Eurojust is strengthening international cooperation on accountability for crimes in Ukraine. The supplied report gives no basis for judging what that cooperation has achieved. Its ethical importance lies in the work it concerns: how an injury suffered by a person becomes a matter others are prepared to investigate, establish and answer for.

Cooperation deserves support where it makes that work possible. It does not deserve an exemption from scrutiny simply because its stated purpose is good.

A commitment to accountability has to include responsibility for the means by which guilt is established. Otherwise, we risk treating procedure as an irritating obstacle between our certainty and someone else’s punishment. That temptation is hardly confined to wartime. It appears whenever belonging to the right side begins to feel like sufficient evidence that we are right about everything.

The obvious objection is that caution can become a comfortable refuge. People can invoke complexity indefinitely while those who have suffered wait. A process may observe its rules and still fail through delay, indifference or an unwillingness to act. Fairness cannot mean giving institutions unlimited time to produce nothing.

Both dangers have to remain visible. We need procedures strong enough to resist a demand for a convenient verdict, and institutions open enough to explain why progress has stalled. Neither public anger nor professional reassurance should settle the matter.

For anyone trying to think seriously about how we live together, this reaches beyond courts. Responsibility includes accepting constraints on the power we want exercised on our behalf. It means asking what would count as evidence against our preferred conclusion, even when asking feels disloyal.

For a person waiting to have a wrong recognised, these distinctions can seem unbearably remote. That is a reason to make justice work with greater care and urgency. It is no reason to make its conclusions easier to purchase with certainty.