Article

Political Loyalty Must Leave Room for Changing Your Mind

5 November 2026

Changing a vote can mean admitting that something you once trusted no longer deserves the same confidence. That is an uncomfortable thing to do, especially when political allegiance has become entangled with family, friendship and your understanding of yourself. Yet a democracy depends on people retaining that freedom, including the freedom to disappoint their own side.

The Guardian reports that Todd Cox, a 63-year-old technology professional in Maine, voted for Democratic Senate challenger Troy Jackson after previously supporting Republican incumbent Susan Collins twice. He described concern about the country’s direction and what he saw as disregard for the rule of law. That is his assessment, reported by the newspaper. One voter’s explanation cannot establish what an electorate thinks.

It does, however, give us something worth examining: whether loyalty still permits judgement.

There is a danger in treating consistency as a virtue regardless of what we are being consistent about. A belief can begin as a considered judgement and become, through repetition, something we feel obliged to defend. Eventually we are protecting our earlier decision from scrutiny. Politics offers plenty of opportunities for this, because every failure can be excused by pointing towards somebody worse.

Still, it would be too easy to praise a voter concerned about constitutional conduct while looking down on someone whose immediate concern is affordability. If keeping a home warm or paying for food absorbs your attention, a demand to think about institutions may sound like it comes from someone with fewer bills.

The difficulty is that these concerns cannot safely be kept apart. Rules governing public power help determine whether ordinary people can challenge decisions that damage their lives. Equally, a political order that promises fair treatment while leaving people unable to manage daily life gives them reason to question its worth.

Living together requires us to make our loyalties answerable to what happens to people. That includes people whose priorities frustrate us.

Changing sides is no guarantee of sound judgement. Staying put is no proof of thoughtlessness. The useful test is whether any evidence could alter our position, and whether we apply that test to those we support. If our preferred representatives can never lose our support, we have given away one of the few means we possess of making them listen.