A person can have very little influence over a government and still be expected to absorb the consequences of its conduct. That is a difficulty whenever economic pressure is used in the name of human rights. The government is addressed; someone trying to keep a business afloat or earn a wage may receive the message rather more directly.
TheCable reports that the United States is moving to end duty-free trade benefits for South Africa and Rwanda over human rights concerns. The supplied report does not establish that these changes have taken effect, or what their consequences would be. It would be premature to describe particular jobs or livelihoods as already lost.
But the ethical problem does not have to wait for a balance sheet.
If a measure is justified by concern for human beings, its likely effects on those human beings belong inside the justification. They cannot be left until afterwards, when hardship becomes an unfortunate complication of an otherwise principled decision. People have to live through the interval between pressure being applied and any hoped-for improvement.
There is a serious objection here. Continuing a trading advantage can also be a choice with consequences. A government should not be able to make itself immune from pressure simply because others might suffer when that pressure arrives. Taken far enough, that argument would give those in power a permanent shelter behind the people they govern.
So the choice cannot be settled by calling economic pressure either principled or cruel. It requires a harder account: how is the proposed measure expected to change conduct, who is likely to bear its costs, and what would count as evidence that it is failing? A policy needs some means of being corrected without that correction being treated as moral surrender.
For an evolving philosophy of how we live together, this reaches beyond trade. We routinely judge our own actions by their declared purpose while judging other people’s actions by their effects. Power makes that habit dangerous.
A human rights justification should therefore invite closer scrutiny of a policy, including scrutiny from people exposed to its consequences. Their account may be inconvenient. If it cannot alter the decision, we should ask how much their rights actually figured in making it.