Article

An Accusation Must Not Decide Who Deserves Rights

3 November 2026

For someone accused of terrorism, the punishment can begin before any court has reached a decision. People who might otherwise listen may decide that listening itself looks suspicious. A family seeking answers can find that it must first explain why its relative deserves to be heard at all.

That is the human danger worth examining in the claim made by Brighter Kashmir that human rights activists in Pakistan are being treated as terrorists. The headline supplied here does not establish what happened in individual cases, what evidence exists or how authorities have justified their actions. It would be irresponsible to settle those questions from a headline. It would also be a mistake to overlook the ethical problem it presents.

An accusation cannot be allowed to determine whether the accused retains the right to challenge it. Otherwise, the authority making the accusation also acquires the power to place its own conduct beyond effective scrutiny.

There is a serious complication. Calling oneself a human rights activist does not confer innocence. Governments have responsibilities towards people threatened by violence, and an organisation’s stated purpose cannot substitute for examining what its members actually do. Evidence may justify prosecution. The difficulty is that this argument works in both directions: the language of national security cannot substitute for evidence either.

For those of us watching from a distance, responsibility begins with resisting the convenience of the label. We cannot investigate every case ourselves. We can, however, refuse to treat an official designation as a completed argument. We can ask whether a person has a meaningful opportunity to answer allegations, and whether criticism of the authorities is being confused with a threat to the public.

An open philosophy of living together has to leave room for people who trouble the prevailing account of things. Some will be mistaken. Some may behave unlawfully. Their claims still require examination, and their treatment still concerns the rest of us.

Once we accept that certain accusations make questions improper, we have handed whoever controls those accusations an extraordinary privilege. They no longer need to persuade us that their actions are justified. They need only persuade us that the person asking should not be heard.