A decade is a substantial part of a human life. Someone grows up during it. Someone grows old waiting for circumstances to change. When we hear that a human rights situation has shown no improvement over ten years, the language can make it sound as though time itself has stood still. It has carried on, taking possibilities with it.
Voice of America reports that a UN official says North Korea’s human rights situation has not improved over the past decade. That is an attributed assessment, and the supplied reporting does not establish the circumstances of individual people. It nevertheless asks something uncomfortable of any philosophy concerned with a human future: what grounds do we have for assuming that the passage of time will make that future better?
Progress is an attractive inheritance. We can absorb it almost without noticing, imagining that greater knowledge, more communication or simply another generation will gradually loosen the hold of cruelty. Yet a future arrives whether anybody has made it more humane or not. Waiting can become a way of leaving our assumptions untested.
There is a danger in this argument. Insisting that something must change can make almost any dramatic intervention sound preferable to patience. People whose lives are already constrained should not also have to bear the consequences of outsiders needing to feel effective. Urgency does not establish that a proposed action will help.
But caution needs examination too. Whose risks are being weighed? Who pays for delay? A responsible response has to ask what evidence would justify continuing an approach, and what evidence would require changing it. Otherwise, an unsuccessful course can acquire authority merely by lasting.
This matters beyond one country. In our own institutions and relationships, we readily mistake endurance for legitimacy. An arrangement survives; eventually its survival becomes part of the argument for keeping it.
A philosophy of living together must leave room to challenge that argument. It must also accept the difficult work that follows: listening to those affected, testing proposed changes and admitting when an answer has failed. Ten years without improvement should disturb our confidence in whatever we thought time would accomplish for us. The people living through those years cannot recover them when our thinking finally catches up.