Article

Our Dependence on Each Other Must Not Become a Weapon

27 October 2026

A person can remain inside their own home and still have the conditions of ordinary life taken from them. Walls are only part of what makes a home habitable. Much of the rest arrives through systems nobody in the household can maintain alone.

Electricity makes that dependence unusually visible when it disappears. Before the interruption, there is a socket. Afterwards, there is the discovery of how much of daily life was resting on it.

The Washington Post reports that a UN-backed inquiry has found Russia committed war crimes through attacks on Ukraine’s energy grid. That is an attributed finding, rather than a court judgement established here. The report also brings a wider ethical problem into view: what happens when the systems through which people sustain one another become a means of exerting pressure on them?

Any philosophy concerned with how people live together has to take this dependence seriously. We often discuss responsibility as though each person were a self-contained unit, answerable for choices made with resources entirely their own. Yet even the most determinedly independent person relies on strangers to keep water flowing, food available and essential services functioning. There is nothing embarrassing about that. It is how a complex society works.

War makes the implications difficult. Infrastructure can serve both civilian and military purposes. That complication deserves examination; it cannot simply be wished away. But acknowledging it does not settle whether a particular attack is lawful, nor does it make the people dependent on that infrastructure morally disappear. “Dual use” must never become a phrase that does all the thinking for us.

The ethical proposition worth testing is that greater civilian dependence creates a stronger obligation to account for foreseeable harm. The more people rely on a shared system, the less adequate it becomes to discuss its destruction solely in terms of the advantage gained by disabling it.

That has consequences beyond the judgement of individual attacks. Public discussion should press for an account of whose lives a proposed military advantage would disrupt, and how that harm has been weighed. Those questions belong inside the assessment, before action is taken.

Otherwise, the very arrangements that allow people to live together become leverage against them. Building a society takes generations of accumulated reliance. An account of war that notices only what can be destroyed misses what people spent those generations making possible.