For someone facing abuse, the distinction between being ignored for strategic reasons and being ignored through indifference may offer very little comfort. Either way, the people with influence have decided that something else takes priority. Sometimes there are serious reasons for that decision. The person left exposed still has to live with it.
The headline of Goldstein’s Toronto Sun commentary accuses Mark Carney of selective morality on human rights. A headline alone cannot establish whether that judgement is fair, or what particular decisions would support it. But the accusation brings a genuine ethical difficulty into view: how much inconsistency can a commitment to universal rights tolerate before it becomes a preference for particular people?
There is an easy answer which is also inadequate. Demand identical treatment in every circumstance. Governments, however, have different degrees of influence, competing obligations and imperfect choices. Public condemnation may help in one situation and close a useful channel in another. Equal concern does not necessarily produce identical action.
That complication deserves attention. It must not become an unlimited licence.
A defensible difference in approach needs reasons that can be examined. What is the action intended to achieve for those affected? What makes silence useful here? What evidence would show that the chosen approach had failed? Without that possibility of scrutiny, almost any accommodation can be presented as patient diplomacy.
There is a responsibility for critics too. An accusation of hypocrisy should withstand the same examination it demands of its target. Otherwise, human rights become another means of injuring a political opponent, while the people whose treatment supposedly matters disappear from the argument.
For an evolving philosophy concerned with how we live together, this is a useful discipline: allow judgement to change with the circumstances, while requiring an account of whose interests the change serves. Revision is necessary. Unexplained convenience deserves suspicion.
The practical consequence is uncomfortable. We have to examine the exceptions we excuse in people we support as seriously as those we condemn in people we oppose. That requires more than noticing inconsistency elsewhere. It requires being willing to withdraw our own permission for it.