Someone whose rights are being disregarded has a particular reason to fear the word “pragmatism”. It can mean that other people have found something more useful to discuss. Their freedom remains important, of course. Just never quite important enough to interrupt the meeting.
CTV News reports that Prime Minister Mark Carney is seeking stronger ties between Canada and Türkiye amid human rights concerns. The supplied report does not establish what commitments are being sought or how those concerns are being addressed. It would be premature to call this either a diplomatic achievement or a moral surrender.
It does, however, offer a useful test: can a government pursue a closer relationship without allowing the people who complicate it to disappear from consideration?
There is a serious argument for engagement. Refusing contact can leave governments with fewer ways to influence one another, and estrangement is hardly a guarantee of better treatment for anyone. A relationship need not amount to approval. We manage that distinction in ordinary life, sometimes with considerable effort.
Yet engagement becomes a convenient word if nothing could ever cause it to change. If human rights concerns are acknowledged but cannot affect the terms, pace or limits of a relationship, what work is the acknowledgement doing? There is a difference between accepting that power has limits and arranging matters so that principle never inconveniences power.
The practical consequence is a duty to explain. A government seeking closer ties should be able to say what it hopes engagement will make possible, how rights concerns enter its decisions, and what would lead it to reconsider. Some negotiations require privacy. That cannot reasonably make the whole ethical basis of a policy confidential.
This also asks something of the rest of us. We cannot demand that governments protect human rights, then treat every resulting inconvenience as proof of incompetence. Principles that cost somebody else everything and ourselves nothing are unusually easy to applaud.
Living together across borders requires dealings with people and governments we cannot simply remake. The difficult task is to keep those dealings open without quietly closing the door on people who need us to remain awkward. A stronger relationship ought to be capable of surviving their presence in the conversation.