A wounded person arriving at a hospital needs other people to make room for something more urgent than allegiance. Whatever brought them there, their body cannot wait for the argument to be settled. A hospital depends on enough people accepting that limit, including people who otherwise agree on very little.
A BBC investigation reports that fighters from Sudan’s Rapid Support Forces deliberately targeted hospitals. The UN human rights chief, Volker Türk, says the multiple attacks may amount to war crimes. That legal assessment matters, and the reported findings require serious scrutiny. Neither should be inflated into claims beyond the evidence available.
But the ethical problem already demands attention. If a place of treatment can be attacked because of whom it might help, then receiving care becomes conditional on somebody else’s permission to remain alive.
It is easy to defend the treatment of innocent people. The harder test comes when the patient is implicated in harm, belongs to a hated group, or might recover and return to fighting. There is a real tension here. Medical care can preserve the life of someone who may later endanger another person.
Yet allowing that possibility to decide who receives treatment gives armed power an extraordinary authority. It can turn any patient’s suspected future into a reason to deny their present need. Suspicion does not have to prove very much once the person holding the weapon also decides what counts as proof.
Treating someone does not settle their innocence. Nor does it cancel responsibility for what they have done. A person can require medical care and still have a case to answer. Keeping those matters separate is difficult precisely when anger has good reasons behind it.
For an open philosophy concerned with how human beings can continue living together, this is a demanding place to begin. Our arrangements must remain usable when affection and agreement have run out. Otherwise they offer little protection at the moment protection becomes necessary.
The practical consequence is uncomfortable: we have to defend access to care even where we cannot offer sympathy to every person receiving it. That leaves accusations to be investigated and responsibility to be established. It also leaves a doctor able to attend to the person in front of them without first resolving the war.