Someone whose views we find repellent may still need our help. That is an awkward place to begin a conversation about human rights, because sympathy usually comes more easily when we can recognise something of ourselves in the person being harmed. We hear their story and imagine our own family. With someone we distrust, we start looking for qualifications.
Punch Newspapers reports that advocates have warned against selective defence of human rights. The supplied report gives no further detail about the people or circumstances involved, so it cannot support a judgement about a particular dispute. The warning nevertheless points towards a serious problem: how easily a commitment to human rights can become conditional on who happens to need them.
There is a distinction worth protecting here. A person can be responsible for wrongdoing and still be entitled to fair treatment. Defending that entitlement does not require us to soften our judgement of what they have done. Indeed, the ability to hold both thoughts at once is part of what makes a justice system possible. Otherwise, accusation begins doing the work of a verdict, and dislike becomes permission.
The obvious complication is that nobody can defend everyone, everywhere, with equal energy. People have limited time and knowledge. A campaigner may understand one injustice deeply and know almost nothing about another. Someone defending a threatened neighbour should not have to demonstrate a complete record of concern for humanity before being taken seriously.
Selectivity of attention is unavoidable. Selectivity about who qualifies for protection is a different matter.
The difficulty comes when our silence serves an allegiance rather than a limitation. When we would recognise mistreatment immediately if it happened to our friends, yet become wonderfully patient with explanations when our opponents suffer it. We may even call this patience balance.
An evolving philosophy of living together has to make room for revising such habits. That requires more than declaring ourselves compassionate. It means accepting restraints on what we permit our own side to do, including when those restraints are inconvenient and the person benefiting offers us no gratitude.
There will always be arguments about the facts of a case. Evidence matters, and uncertainty should remain visible. But “I dislike this person” adds nothing to the evidence. If it changes the protection we think they deserve, we have allowed our feelings to acquire an authority they cannot safely be given.