Article

The Price of Speaking Should Not Depend on Who Speaks

22 October 2026

A journalist can expect to have their work challenged. Their evidence may be questioned, their judgement disputed, their conclusions pulled apart. But when the price of doing the job includes abuse directed at their gender, something else is being decided: who must endure an additional punishment for entering public life.

That punishment matters even when it fails to silence anyone. We should be wary of measuring harm only by whether a person eventually gives up. Staying at work does not make everything endured along the way acceptable.

A report shared on Facebook says the Commission on Human Rights has called on media organisations to protect journalists against gender-based abuse and improve reporting concerning women and LGBTQIA+ people. The supplied summary gives no detail about particular incidents or proposed safeguards. It does, however, bring two responsibilities into view: how a newsroom treats the people doing its work, and how it treats the people whose lives become its subject.

These responsibilities meet at a difficult point. Journalism needs the freedom to make people uncomfortable. Respect for someone’s rights cannot reasonably mean that their actions, arguments or institutions become exempt from investigation. A commitment to humane reporting would be rather hollow if it required abandoning inconvenient truths.

Yet there is nothing intellectually demanding about turning someone’s identity into an insult. Nor does a report become more searching because it invites an audience to regard a whole category of people with contempt. The useful distinction is between challenging something a person can answer for and making their existence the charge against them.

For media organisations, taking that distinction seriously has consequences. A journalist facing targeted abuse should not have to prove professional toughness by managing it alone. An editor also has to ask whether a description helps readers understand a story, or merely supplies a familiar prejudice with fresh material. Neither judgement can be outsourced entirely to a policy document.

There is a temptation to treat public life as a test of who can tolerate the worst behaviour. That gives those willing to behave worst an extraordinary amount of power over who gets heard.

If we want people to participate in a shared future, we have to examine the terms of participation. The work may properly be difficult. We need not defend every difficulty imposed on the person doing it.