Someone seeking help with a violation of their rights may already have spent months explaining themselves to people who control what happens next. Another organisation arrives, perhaps with an ingenious approach. There is still a difficult question beneath the offer of help: how much say will this person have in what is done in their name?
UC Berkeley Law reports that its Global Rights Innovation Lab Clinic is advancing several projects it describes as groundbreaking. The supplied report title does not establish what those projects involve or what they have achieved. It does, however, offer a useful occasion to examine the promise contained in the word “innovation”. In human rights work, novelty needs a more demanding test than institutional enthusiasm.
A worthwhile starting proposition is that work undertaken to defend people’s rights should increase their practical ability to influence decisions affecting them. That includes decisions made by those offering assistance. Otherwise, even a well-intentioned project can preserve an old arrangement: expertise speaks, the person concerned supplies the experience, and authority remains where it was.
There is a complication. Expertise matters. A person facing an urgent threat cannot reasonably be expected to master every legal procedure before receiving help. Nor should consultation become an elaborate ritual that delays useful action while allowing everyone involved to feel conscientious.
The difficulty is deciding where expertise is necessary and where it becomes an excuse for retaining control. A lawyer may understand which argument has a chance in court. The person whose life could be exposed by that argument understands consequences the lawyer may never have to live with. Both kinds of knowledge belong in the decision.
For an evolving philosophy concerned with how people live together, this reaches beyond legal clinics. We routinely inherit arrangements in which some people define the problem and others must qualify for help. Revising those arrangements requires more than inviting the latter group to speak. Their contribution must be capable of changing the plan.
That is a practical test for any promising rights initiative: can the people it serves question its assumptions, refuse its proposed course, or require it to change? The answers may make a project slower and less impressive to announce. They may also reveal whether it has transferred any power at all.