Article

The Right to Refuse Must Survive Our Concern

17 October 2026

A person refuses psychiatric treatment. Someone responsible for their care believes that refusal will expose them to serious harm. Neither concern nor refusal can settle what happens next, yet the person with the power to act may be tempted to treat their own certainty as sufficient permission.

That is the ethical difficulty beneath the report in The Manila Times that Citizens Commission on Human Rights International has called on US states to end coercive psychiatric practices, following a WHO report described as detailing risks to human rights. The reported demand is clear. The headline alone does not establish the WHO report’s precise findings or recommendations.

The proposition worth examining is that a refusal must remain meaningful even when others consider it mistaken. If the right to refuse exists only when we make choices that professionals approve of, it offers very little protection at the moment we might need it most.

This does not make every refusal an informed decision. Nor does it remove the frightening possibility that a person may be unable, at a particular moment, to understand a danger. Someone facing an immediate crisis cannot always wait for a philosophical dispute to be resolved. An absolute prohibition on intervention must answer for what happens to people who cannot presently protect themselves.

But an emergency cannot become a permanent explanation. If exceptional authority is justified by a particular danger, it should have to answer to that danger: why this intervention, why now, and why could something less restrictive not suffice? The obligation to explain should grow with the power being exercised.

There is another difficulty. Once disagreement has been interpreted as evidence of incapacity, how does a person disagree with that interpretation? A system can become impossible to challenge without anyone consciously deciding to make it so.

Any serious reform therefore has to reach beyond statements of good intent. It must give a person a usable way to question what is being done to them, obtain help in expressing their wishes, and have restrictions reconsidered by someone able to change the decision.

Those protections may complicate care. They may take time when time is scarce. Yet convenience cannot decide how much authority one human being holds over another. The person who says no still has to be heard, especially when someone else has the power to make that no disappear.