Article

Inclusion Must Leave Room for an Inconvenient Answer

15 October 2026

Being asked what happened to you is one thing. Being able to influence what happens next is another. A process can make room for someone’s testimony while leaving every important decision beyond their reach.

That distinction matters whenever a society attempts to address past abuses. People may be invited to speak, yet still discover that the acceptable destination has been chosen before they arrive. Even a sincere invitation can contain an unspoken condition: please participate in the future we have already designed.

The Ethiopian Human Rights Commission reports that it and civil society organisations are strengthening their coordination to support an inclusive transitional justice process in Ethiopia. That is a stated purpose worth taking seriously. The supplied reporting does not establish how much influence affected people will have, or whether this coordination will change their experience of seeking justice.

The ethical test lies there. Inclusion should make a process capable of being changed by the people it includes. Otherwise, listening risks becoming a way of securing agreement rather than discovering what needs doing.

There is a difficulty, though. Those who have suffered will not necessarily agree with one another. Nor does suffering make anyone infallible. One person’s preferred resolution may be unacceptable to someone else, and a public process cannot promise that every demand will prevail. Taking people seriously requires enough honesty to say this, rather than offering participation as a promise nobody can keep.

What it can offer is a meaningful route from speech to decision: an explanation of what was heard, what changed because of it, and why some requests were refused. A refusal that can be questioned is different from a silence that cannot.

This reaches beyond the design of justice institutions. We often welcome other people’s contributions until they disturb our account of ourselves. Then disagreement becomes an obstacle, and we begin wishing for more cooperative participants.

An evolving philosophy of living together has to leave its own assumptions exposed to that disturbance. So must any institution asking people to trust a shared future. If those invited into the room cannot challenge its terms, the invitation remains unfinished.