Article

Human Rights Cannot Depend on Who Remains to Defend Them

14 October 2026

For someone whose rights are disputed, the presence of an advocate can make an enormous difference. There is another person willing to insist that the matter deserves attention, particularly when everyone else would rather move on. Losing such a person brings a difficult question into view: how much of our protection depends on somebody continuing to make a nuisance of themselves on our behalf?

CBC reports that Irene Mathyssen, the longtime NDP MP in London, has died at 75. Its headline remembers her for her advocacy for human rights. That is a meaningful way to describe a public life, though it cannot, by itself, tell us what that work achieved or how those affected experienced it.

It does invite us to examine what happens when responsibility becomes closely associated with particular people.

There is comfort in having recognised defenders of human rights. We know whom to admire, whom to consult, perhaps whom to call when something goes wrong. The difficulty begins when their commitment becomes an excuse for everyone else’s absence. A society can praise its advocates lavishly while leaving them to carry work that ought to be shared.

Yet there is a complication here. Commitment cannot simply be distributed by instruction. Some people have greater knowledge, persistence or opportunity than others. Public advocacy needs those differences. Expecting everyone to do everything would quickly become an excuse to do nothing properly.

The more useful demand is narrower: wherever we exercise power over another person, we should be answerable for how we use it. That includes the unremarkable power to dismiss a complaint, delay a decision or treat someone’s exclusion as an administrative inconvenience. Much of the need for advocacy begins in places where nobody thinks they are doing anything especially consequential.

For an evolving philosophy concerned with how we live together, remembrance therefore has a practical edge. It asks us to examine the arrangements we have become comfortable with, including those that function only because a determined person keeps challenging them.

Honouring an advocate need not mean agreeing with every position they held. It can mean becoming less willing to leave the next person seeking fair treatment to find a champion before anyone will listen.