A person should be able to disagree with the beliefs surrounding them without losing the ability to find others, organise and speak. That seems a modest requirement for living together. It becomes considerably less modest when the disagreement concerns sexuality, identity or the kind of life someone is allowed to lead.
OHCHR reports that UN experts have expressed alarm about a crackdown on LGBTI human rights defenders and civil society organisations in Türkiye. The supplied report does not establish the details of individual cases, so it would be wrong to manufacture them. But the concern it describes brings a particular ethical problem into view: what happens when people’s capacity to defend one another becomes something authorities seek to restrict?
There is a temptation to treat freedom as an individual possession. You have your convictions; someone else has theirs. Yet a person standing alone has very different possibilities from a person who can seek advice, meet others and challenge a decision with support. Freedom depends partly on whether those relationships are allowed to exist.
The objection deserves an answer. Civil society organisations are not beyond scrutiny, and invoking human rights cannot exempt anyone from laws protecting others against harm. Equally, a claim to be defending society does not settle whether a restriction is justified. The conduct being restricted matters. Disapproval of the people involved cannot do the work of evidence.
For an open philosophy concerned with how we live together, this reaches beyond a dispute about particular beliefs. Inherited convictions may be deeply meaningful. They may also need revising. If their preservation requires removing the people who challenge them from public life, we have made revision harder precisely where it may be most necessary.
Silence then becomes dangerously easy to misread. A community may appear united because those who disagree cannot safely make themselves heard. That appearance offers very little evidence that its beliefs are sound.
The practical responsibility is to defend the conditions under which disagreement remains possible, including for people whose lives we do not understand. Before accepting a restriction as reasonable, ask what conduct warrants it and whether those affected can contest it. If they cannot, the rest of us are being offered a version of public agreement with some of the participants missing.